Do the Pope
If you did the Pope Vs. Muhammad that would be funny. But not Jesus vs. Muhammad! Jesus is the Son of God! According to Muslim believes Muhammad was a prophet! Their is a difference between Son of God, and Prophet... now if you did the Pope, that might make me, even as a Christian want to see it.
Now Jesus told us to love others because we are going to Heaven, while Muhammad tells us to kill and hate others to get into Heaven!
Which do you prefer?
Or an even better Idea would be:
Mel Gibson Vs. Muhammud! That would be hillarious.
Anyway, if you use Jesus in it, you can be sure that you'll never see me watch it.